Sandy Pony Donuts – Chincoteague Island, VA

This morning we tried Sandy Pony Donuts. As soon as they handed me the box, the bottom felt warm. I'm thinking all the donuts start warm and are custom made. They appear smaller in size but they have some weight to them. We ordered a variety so we can sample them. My step daughter has a peanut allergy so they recommended to stay away from the chocolate chips bc the chocolate chips are near the peanuts. The girls were very patient in helping us select our dozen. My favorite was the bacon donut.

Eric McDermott

A must have when on the island! Love customizing the donuts and having them prepared hot and fresh for us! The pony and island themed names are a fun touch. Always enjoy!

Karen Peachey

This donut spot is wonderful! The donuts are perfectly hot and fresh with a wide variety of flavors. In the years I’ve been stopping here, I finally tried their açaí bowls and they were fantastic (probably even my favorite that I’ve ever tried). Decent topping options and they didn’t turn soupy right away. Line can be long, but it moves surprisingly quick.

Taylor Lamb

Delicious Donuts and gluten free options were so good! I got cinnamon and powdered

Cynthia Lam

I loved stopping here for some fresh donuts and iced coffee. The staff was patient while we looked at the expansive menu offerings. The iced coffee was refreshing and the donuts were divine. I loved the Porky bacon donut the best however the fruity pebble donut was also a top contender. Highly recommend and cannot wait to be back.

Andrea Kuoni

Maddie always makes the best açaí bowls at Sandy Pony Chincoteague Island!!! And the donuts are always warm and fresh!!! Love it all! 🍩 🐴

Rebecca Beebe Farrell